What’s Wrong With This House: Stately Capitol Hill Home

This grand abode has been on the market for 1,286 days. Why?

By Lauren Mang December 17, 2014

exteriorweb

[addtoany]

Each month, we crawl through real estate listings on various websites searching for homes–in all sorts of price points and locations–that for some reason, just haven’t found the right person or family to call their own. Sad. But why haven’t these seemingly lovely dwellings sold? A few months ago we featured this one (which shockingly still hasn’t been scooped up) and got tons of great reader theories as to its continued market presence. My favorite: That it was haunted by a wealthy ghost.

For our current installment, we look to this natural light-filled, Georgian Revival-style beauty, built in 1906 and perched atop a hill along 22nd Avenue E. The six-bedroom abode has an immense 6,665 square feet and a stunning central entrance hall from which the other first-floor rooms flow. (Oh, the holiday gatherings one could host!)

Architectural details abound: Coffered ceilings, ornate columns and crown moulding, oak floors, original radiators (so now), a converted vintage McCray icebox in the kitchen. If you’re looking for charm with some swell mountain views to boot, this place certainly has it. So what’s the problem?

For one, there’s a high price tag attached (the home is listed for $2,288,000) and a few of the rooms–mainly the bathrooms–look a tad outdated. Maybe it’s too much charm for buyers to handle? Or could the strangely-worded, overly flowery property description on the real estate site be a possible barrier? Take a look at the photos below to speculate why you think this Capitol Hill home hasn’t sold.


Gorgeous central entrance way. Slightly conjurs Grey Gardens, no?


Sitting pretty in this living room, complete with a fireplace


A breakfast room sits off the kitchen; there is also a formal dining room


The kitchen is a cool mix of new and old


Pretty bedroom, but the blue carpet is meh


One of the home’s 3.75 baths. Could it’s outdated style be one of the reasons it hasn’t sold?


Adore this porch; so Blanche Devereaux

So what do you think? Tweet us your theories on what’s wrong with this house and we’ll retweet the best answers we get!

 

Follow Us

Montlake Maximalists

Montlake Maximalists

Couple strips 1915 Dutch colonial home

Subscribers to the minimalist movement that has dominated American interior design over the past decade-plus may be roughly cleaved into two demographic groups...

Picture Perfect, Inside and Out

Picture Perfect, Inside and Out

The Friedman home serves as a rotating art gallery

"Canoe Trails Residence” is a home art gallery designed with velvet gloves and without velvet ropes. For decades, Ken and Jane Friedman have been serious curators and creators of art. Jane formerly co-owned Friedman Oens Gallery on Bainbridge Island, acquiring notable pieces from around the Northwest and world. Their collection includes...

PCF Wins Prestigious Remodeler's Award

PCF Wins Prestigious Remodeler’s Award

PCF Construction Group nabs awards for excellence and integrity

[addtoany]People Come First (PCF) Construction Group has been building dream outdoor living spaces for homeowners across the Pacific Northwest for more than 15 years. The Kent-based builder was named National Remodeler of the Year by the National Association of Home Builders (NAHB) in 2023, and a National Finalist in 2024. “Receiving the Remodeler of the…

Small-Scale Sensitivity

Small-Scale Sensitivity

Whole-house renovation respects the aesthetics of its Capitol Hill neighborhood

Miriam Larson founded Story Architecture in the belief that, if she dug deep enough, each house and the family that lives in it would have a story to tell. In time, she would also conclude that some books are perfectly happy to be judged by their covers.